SP Betting as a Self-Enforcing Implicit Cartel

Main Article Content

Adi Schnytzer
Avichai Snir


A large share of the UK off-course horse racing betting market involves winning payouts determined at Starting Prices (SP). This implies that gamblers can bet with off-course bookies on any horse before a race at the final pre-race odds as set by on-course bookies for that horse.Given the oligopolistic structure of the off-course gambling market in the UK, a market that is dominated by a small number of large bookmaking firms, we study the phenomenon of SP as a type of self-enforcing implicit collusion. We show that given the uncertainty about a race outcome, and their ability to influence the prices set by on-course bookies, agreeing to lay bets at SP is superior for off-course bookies as compared with offering fixed odds. We thus extend the results of Rotemberg and Saloner (1990) to markets with uncertainty about both demand and outcomes,We test our model by studying the predicted effects of SP betting on the behavior of on-course bookies. Using data drawn from both the UK and Australian on-course betting markets, we show that the differences between these markets are consistent with the predicted effects of SP betting in the UK off-course market and its absence from the Australian market.

Article Details



Borenstein Severin and Andrea Shepard (1996), "Dynamic Pricing in Retail Gasoline Markets," 27,3: 429-451.

Bruce, Alistair C. and Johnnie E.V. Johnson (2005), "Market Ecology and Decision Behavior in State-Contingent Claims Markets," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 56: 199-217.

Busche, Kelly and Christopher Hall (1988), "An Exception to the Risk Preference Anomaly," Journal of Business 61: 337-346.

Carlton, D.W. and J. M. Perloff (1994), Modern Industrial Organization, 3rd edition, (New York, NY: Harper-Collins-College-Publishers).

Crafts N.F.R (1985), "Some Evidence of Insider Knowledge in Horse Race Betting in Britain," Economica 52,207: 295-304.

Dowie, Jack (1976), "On the Efficiency and Equity of Betting Markets," Economica 43,170: 139-150.

Figlewski, Stephen (1979), "Subjective Information and Market Efficiency in a Betting Market," Journal of Political Economy 87,1: 75-88.

Gabriel, Paul E. and Marsden James R. (1990), "An Examination of Market Efficiency in British Racetrack Betting," Journal of Political Economy 98,4: 874-885.

Gandar, John, M., Richard A. Zuber and R. Stafford Johnson (2001), "Searching for the Favourite-Longshot Bias Down Under: An Examination of the New-Zealand Pari-Mutuel Betting Market," Applied Economics 33: 1621-1629.

Hurley, Williams and Lawrence McDonough (1995), "A Note on the Hayek Hypothesis and the Favorite Long Shot Bias in Pari-mutuel Betting," American Economic Review 85,4: 949-955.

Johnson, Johnnie E.V. and Sung (2006), "Revealing Weak Form Inefficiency in a Market for State Contingent Claims," Working Paper.

Law, David and David A. Peel (2002), "Insider Trading, Herding Behavior and Market Plungers in the British Horse-race Betting Market," Economic Journal 69, 327 – 338.

Lee, Marcus and Gary Smith (2002), "Regression to the Mean and Football Wagers,"

Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 15: 329-342.

Levitt, Steven D. (2004), "Why are Gambling Markets Organized so Differently from Financial Markets?" Economic Journal 114: 223-246.

Rotemberg, and Saloner (1990), "Collusive Price Leadership," journal of Industrial Economics 39,1: 93-111.

Sauer, Raymond D. (1998), "The Economics of Wagering Markets," Journal of Economic Literature 36,4: 2021-2064.

Schnytzer, Adi and Yuval Shilony (1995) ,"Inside Information in a Betting Market," Economic Journal 105: 963-971.

Schnytzer, Adi and Yuval Shilony (2003), "Is the Presence of Inside Traders Necessary to Give Rise to a Favorite-Longshot Bias?" in L. Vaughan Williams (ed.) The Economics of Gambling, Routledge, 14-17.

Schnytzer, Adi and Yuval Shilony (2005), "Insider-Trading and Bias in a Market for State-Contingent Claims," in L. Vaughn Williams (ed.) Information Efficiency in Financial and Betting Markets, Cambridge University Press, 287-312.

Shin, Hyun Song (1993), "Measuring the Incidence of Insider Trading in a Market for State-Contingent Claims," Economic Journal 103,420: 1141-1153.

Shin, Hyun Song (1992), "Prices of State Contingent Claims with Insider Traders and Favorite-Longshot Bias," Economic Journal 102,411: 426-435.

Shin, Hyun Song (1991), "Optimal Betting Odds against Insider Traders," Economic Journal 101,408: 1179-1185.

Slade, Margaret E. (1992), "Vancouver's Gasoline Price Wars: An Empirical Exercise in Uncovering Supergame Strategies," Review of Economic Studies 59,2: 257-276.

Strumpf, Koleman S. (2003), "Illegal Sports Bookmakers," Working Paper.

Thaler, Richard H. and Williams T. Ziemba (1988), "Anomalies: Pari-mutuel Betting Markets: Racetrack and Lotteries," Journal of Economic Perspective 2,2:161-174.

Vaughan Williams, Leighton and David Paton (1997), "Why is there a favorite-Longshot Bias in British Racetrack Betting Markets?" Economic Journal 107,440: 150-158.